Collateral Censorship: Theory and Evidence from Venezuela
Hybrid Event: Join Zoom Meeting: https://bsg.zoom.us/j/91663686066?pwd=QWNHVEY4YzhWMUtvMHZmN0RKQWsyQT09, Meeting ID: 916 6368 6066, Passcode: 322203
Literature on censorship in competitive authoritarian regimes identifies a simple tradeoff: muffling an opposition media outlet can reduce voters’ exposure to anti-incumbent news content, but may also erode the incumbent’s own ability to communicate. This characterization neglects indirect benefits and costs of censoring an opposition media outlet: collateral censorship. By weakening competition in media markets, the incumbent allows allied media outlets to further bend their editorial lines in his favor. But voters may punish the incumbent for restricting access to valued programming. We formalize this trade-off in a stylized Bayesian persuasion model that guides our analysis of the Venezuelan case. When the government of Hugo Chávez revoked the broadcast license of a major television station, voters without cable lost access. Using new data and a difference-in-differences design, we find that these voters punished Chávez at the polls—suggesting that the electoral cost of taking away popular programs exceeded the electoral benefits of restricting access to media criticism among voters without cable. But the decision may have helped Chávez in the electorate as a whole, by inducing favorable shifts in the editorial lines of other outlets. Our findings underscore the relevance of collateral censorship—indirect consequences of targeting opposition outlets—for media freedom in competitive authoritarian regimes.
Date:
17 May 2022, 12:30 (Tuesday, 4th week, Trinity 2022)
Venue:
Nuffield College, New Road OX1 1NF
Venue Details:
Clay Room
Speaker:
John Marshall (Columbia University)
Organising department:
Nuffield College
Organisers:
Ezequiel Gonzalez Ocantos (Nuffield College),
Pepper Culpepper (Nuffield College),
Professor Jane Green (Nuffield College)
Organiser contact email address:
maxine.collett@nuffield.ox.ac.uk
Part of:
Nuffield College Political Science Seminars
Booking required?:
Not required
Audience:
Members of the University only
Editor:
Maxine Collett
